Introduction:
As
human being male or female we carry some sense of knowledge. Our own distinct
set of knowledge-based ideas, thoughts, concepts, and so on. While still
undergoing research, we try to understand the concepts of knowledge and how
everyone learns. For this paper we will review Feminine Pedagogy and how it
plays its role in learning the concept of knowledge, and how it is used in
everyday practices. It begins with the pedagogical framework firm with feminist
theory while also inviting epistemological theories, teaching strategies,
approaches to content, in the classroom and the relationships between the
teacher and the students, considering knowledge to be socially constructed.
Pedagogy
is today more commonly known as the approach to teaching, while referring to
the practice of learning- how is the social, political and psychological
development of the learner influenced by such process. Like feminist pedagogy
studying the interactions that are taking place in the classroom, only feminist
pedagogy is adopted by female teachers to use as teaching strategies,
considering theories of learning, tuning in with the students and their needs,
knowing their interests and beliefs. Creating a new method of teaching outside
of the classroom and addressing society. Breaking it down basically into these
parts.
·
Life experiences=life lessons
·
Break down knowledge- (epistemological)
·
Gender, race, all are one.
Overall
being a part of this pedagogy it’s to make a change in the everyday classroom,
looking at the teacher/ student relationship as equal and allowing the student
to control their learning. Believing that todays classroom and way of teaching
is too dominating and can make the students feel as if they are less. Teachers
and Students should have a type of relationship that leaves negotiation and
interaction (an open-ended process). Feminist Pedagogy- believe gender is
important in the classroom relating to how things are taught in the classroom.
Students should understand the have the right to speak their minds replacing old
teaching ways and bringing on a new era of teaching and learning encouraging a
student to always be mindful of experience and their environment.
Themes:
Gender Power in the Classroom
It
is argued that this learning style is strongly for women and speaking their
mind, although with such focus on gender qualities it allows them to be aware
of the current social issues that are occurring currently. As some would say, a
sexist practice that encourages the gender separation issue that already
exists. Others argue that other pedagogies could be more beneficial and more
gender neutral for learning opportunities and completing education.
In
early education scholars
have taken a look at how being gender conscious can be beneficial in teaching
gender conscious pedagogy(Warin,
Jo, and Vina Adriany, 2017)
With it being said that ECE is
supposedly the most of gendered professions- where it is important to have both
the masculine and feminine side of things in the classroom with the young
minds. A recent article examined two interview-based studies one conducted in
Indonesia and Sweden- Kindergarten and Pre School. Its important to state that
in these findings many of the teachers within the classroom are more than
likely to teach around their (own implicit gender belief”) (Warin,
Jo, and Vina Adriany, 2017) meaning
what they believe if affecting how they teach different subjects or lessons.
For them to be effective in teaching gender pedagogy they need to have more of
an open mind and develop an “explicit gender consciousness). This relieves the
gender bias, allows for more open-minded ideas and thoughts between the student
and the teachers.
Teaching and using Feminist pedagogy
could find some challenges while trying to education and provide interventions
to students in Violence against women in sexuality and relationships. It one
article it states that based on the interview data the programs that were run
heavily with liberal and radical feminist approaches(Ollis,2017)
Reason being to this showing concern
to researchers and other staff, there have been some negative responses from
students, in which they are more aware of sexism, objectifying and sexual
safety. It can be difficult to conduct the approach and is limited in practical
use according to scholars. It started with younger woman started to show more
skin, wear clothes that attracted men in a sexual way compared to the opposite
of woman that did not like their gender and walked around more like a “tomboy”
(Ollis,2017)
In the article above 3 classrooms
were given the opportunity to take part in a Gender and Positive Education
Program for both Male and Female Students, overall 23 females and 27 males in 9th
grade participated, one classroom declined because they believed it was to
traumatizing for their students. Much data was taken and collected on each
group, teacher and then a reflection from both at the end of the program. In
conclusion, many questions were raised on how the material was covered and
shows an increase of awareness in inequality and sexual exploitation of the
woman’s body. With many comments of disgust and surprise that woman “objectify”
themselves and will do anything for money, this was allowing the students and
what seemed to be an emotional connection to the content. It was easier for the
teachers to deconstruct binaries- but still had difficulty with the pedagogical
approaches in (sex/gender) boundaries including the alternative constructs and
re constructs of female sexual desire. (Ollis,2017)
Implications
It seems that feminist(feminism) is
“trending” more in feminist conversations. Especially now that we are more
involved with social media and technology, information can travel faster, and
people feel like they have more of a say on the internet. In relation to this
class a teacher in a read article had stated that she required all her students
in her women and gender studies keep a blog throughout the class- in relation
to Tumblr this allows them to connect with other students along with other
bloggers across the globe that could be conversating on the same topic. They
can use these tools to help learn better in the classroom and stay up to date
on current events. On these blogs students are not joining groups like you can
on other social media sites. With all, we know that outside of going to class
each day these are topics and issues that are discussed. How does this help
with the gender problems that can occur in the classroom?
The teacher will insist to the
students to look for ideas and examples of other types of racism, sexism and
things of that nature(Guillard,2016) Rather it be they are learning
this in the classroom or outside of the classroom students are gaining
knowledge and ideas from the outside world a long with the inside with the hope
that keeping an open mind and understanding of the world around them. Not only
are woman writing about activism but so are mind and having likeminded
conversations and ideas.
It seems that younger than older adults are more pressed on
political issues and this is done via social media. There are many issues that
are identified on social media in relation female users and what some will say
a feminist building block. While we still have the influence from the outside
and other “masculine” so to speak opinions using the social media route. Said
very well by one Author. “As traditional institutions becomes more involved in
social media and build their organizations to include online networks,
educators can support social media sites by using them in social justice
oriented curricula to teach, and become a method for, delivering feminist
activism.”( Guillard,2016 pg 622).
The study conducted was examining
blogging as a feminist pedagogical tool. Many of the topics discussed on these
blogging sites were about women of color, rape, culture, qual rights for LGBTQ,
trans awareness, how media is mis interpreting women and racial privilege.
Although these topics seem to be somewhat overwhelming, many or most of the
students agreed that using blogging as a tool between the classroom and the
outside world was a safe place to have these discussions, in my opinion what I
feel was a great benefit from using this tool, is it did take students outside
of the classroom and out interacting with those who had the same interest and
topics creating more social relationships and no negative effects from teaching
on the subject (Guillard,2016)
Reflection:
As a woman I myself am not concerned
with either gender or prefer to live the life of equality. This very statement
can raise concern for young men and women because of what society has done. We
have reached a stage in our lifetime, where everyone basically knows everything
about you, we all are nosey wondering what our favorite celebrity is doing or
who they are involved with. We all have our own set of belief systems and we
all are never going to agree that this rule should be followed or that this
statement should be allowed to be made. As a woman I enjoy that I can connect
with others on a topic that others believe to be very important and relevant to
their daily lives. If another culture of woman in what some would call to be
degrading or disrespectful if given the opportunity, they will speak their mind
and will do what it takes to make changes that are both beneficial for them and
the generations to pass. Its not only important as a woman but also as a child
or a general human being to stand up for.
Highlights:
I have so many new terms and ideas that need to be addressed and discussed
within this topic. I have just touched the service on this extremely
controversial topic
Process:
Understanding both the masculine and feminine side of any issue is always relevant
and was raised to believe that all are created equal. We have now been faced
with a time where woman and men do not see eye to eye. It’s important for us
educators to see views on each side and stay open minded to those who voice their
concern. As a mother to a daughter, its important as a parent for her to stand
for what she believes and receive appropriate education
Conclusion
When teaching in the classroom I
have now had several teachers either have us keep a journal or blog that was
interactive with other students or those outside campus that could add more to
topics, projects and papers that were done in the classroom. I was skeptical at
first of using a blog and putting out to the world what was going on in my life
and yes this even included the classroom life that I had. It was beneficial for
me because I was actually like the study had mentioned able to connect with
others outside of campus and learn new information that was extremely relevant
and important for my practices.
After reviewing the material and
reading the articles I was shocked as to how big of a controversy this topic is.
Table
2. Summary of Literature Review
|
Theme 1
|
Gender Power in the Classroom
|
Understanding differences in masculine and feminine learning styles.
How the approach is much different
|
|
Theme 2
|
Early Education
|
Scholars have looked at how being
gender conscious can be beneficial in teaching gender conscious pedagogy.
This begins at an early age in younger students.
|
|
Theme 3
|
Learning Outside the Classroom
|
Learning in the classroom leaves little room for growth within the
community and restricts ideas. Expanding to online learning and integrating both
the community and classroom together can increase a more positive learning.
|
References:
Rohrer, Judy. “‘It’s in the Room’: Reinvigorating Feminist Pedagogy,
Contesting Neoliberalism, and Trumping Post-Truth Populism.” Teaching in higher education. 23.5 (2018): 576–592. Web.
Guillard, Julianne. “Is
Feminism Trending? Pedagogical Approaches to Countering (Sl)activism.” Gender
and education. 28.5 (2016): 609–626. W
Herman, Clem, and Gill
Kirkup. “Combining Feminist Pedagogy and Transactional Distance to Create
Gender-Sensitive Technology-Enhanced Learning.” Gender and education.
29.6 (2017): 781–795. Web.
Ollis, Debbie. “The Power
of Feminist Pedagogy in Australia: Vagina Shorts and the Primary Prevention of
Violence Against Women.” Gender and education. 29.4 (2017): 461–475. Web
Warin, Jo, and Vina
Adriany. “Gender Flexible Pedagogy in Early Childhood Education.” Journal of
gender studies. 26.4 (2017): 375–386. Web.
|
Youre
Name
|
Commented
on
|
|
Katee
Welte
|
Mat Murphy Group 5
Transformative Learning
|
Katee,
ReplyDeleteYou did a good job tackling what I would think is a difficult subject. Your paper seemed clear and organized and easy to read, which I appreciate. Also, your literature review had ideas such as keeping a journal, blogging, and using Tublr. To me, they were all new ideas for teaching.. I felt like I learned something!
Gender inequality in the classroom is definitely real. I don’t know if you ever watched Amy Cuddy’s TED Talk, but she talks about something similar when female students in her classes were more shy than the male students. Like you said, technology will allow people to communicate equally, so maybe the problems associated with being a shy student in a competitive school will be diminished.
As I was reading your literature review, I realized that I am guilty of not treating the boys and girls equally in the classroom. To me, the girls are going to do well, and the boys are more likely to struggle. Because of my past experience working with boys, I guess I just stereotype them as being weaker students, especially in reading.
Anyway, good job on what I think is a tough subject.